OLG München on a GmbH shareholder"s fiduciary duty

Even the best of families has arguments, and the same is true for shareholders of a GmbH. Having said that, a ruling of the Oberlandesgericht (OLG) München [Higher Regional Court of Munich] demonstrates that a shareholder’s fiduciary duty does not apply in every case.

Even the best of families has arguments, and the same is true for shareholders of a GmbH. Having said that, a ruling of the Oberlandesgericht (OLG) München [Higher Regional Court of Munich] demonstrates that a shareholder"s fiduciary duty does not apply in every case.

GRP Rainer Lawyers and Tax Advisors in Cologne, Berlin, Bonn, Düsseldorf, Frankfurt, Hamburg, Munich, Stuttgart and London conclude: Shareholders can exercise their voting rights as they please. However, in the case of a Gesellschaft mit beschränkter Haftung (GmbH), a type of German private limited company, this is subject to the restrictions laid out in sec 47(4) of the GmbHG [Act regulating GmbHs] as well as the fiduciary duty under company law. The latter frequently becomes relevant within the scope of disputes arising among the shareholders of a GmbH. A ruling of the Oberlandesgericht München from June 23, 2016 shows that this is not always the case (Az.: 23 U 4531/15).

The case in question before the OLG München concerned a dispute that emerged between two families within a GmbH over the managing director"s successor. Due to the fact that the former managing director had already been removed from his post, there was an urgent need to take appropriate action. However, the two families were not able to reach a consensus regarding a successor, with the result that one side suggested involving a recruitment agency. It being necessary to find a new managing director as a matter of urgency, they argued that the shareholders were required to approve this resolution because of their fiduciary duty, but the other side rejected the resolution.

The OLG München took the view that the shareholders were not obliged to approve the resolution. The fact that a measure or course of action is in the interests of the company, facilitates the company"s objectives and it is reasonable to expect the approval of the shareholders is not enough to justify imposing an obligation on shareholders to approve or view a decision to cast a conflicting vote as invalid. The Court went on to say that inasmuch as shareholders are not obligated to approve as a result of the fiduciary duty, they can reject a proposed measure even if their reasons for doing so seem inappropriate or incomprehensible. According to the case law of the Bundesgerichtshof (BGH), Germany"s Federal Court of Justice, there is only a requirement to vote in a certain way owing to the fiduciary duty if this would mean preserving fundamental values or avoiding substantial losses and the measure to this end is objectively essential and reasonable from the perspective of the shareholders. That being said, the Court clarified that the fiduciary duty does not give rise to an obligation to involve a recruitment agency when urgently searching for a managing director.

To prevent disputes from arising among the shareholders at a later stage, agreements ought to be drafted as precisely as possible. Lawyers who are versed in the field of company law can offer advice in this context.

https://www.grprainer.com/en/legal-advice/company-law/gmbh-limited-liability-company.html (https://www.grprainer.com/en/legal-advice/company-law/gmbh-limited-liability-company.html)

GRP Rainer LLP
Michael Rainer
Augustinerstraße 10
50667 Cologne
+49 221-27 22 75-0
+49 221-27 22 75-24

Contact Details

Company Name: GRP Rainer LLP
Issued By: Michael Rainer
Phone: +49 221-27 22 75-0
Address: Augustinerstraße 10
City: Cologne
State: Nordrhein-Westfalen
Zip: 50667
Country: Germany
Website: Visit the website

Keywords : Lawyer, Lawyers, Attorney,

by Michael Rainer (few months ago!)

Latest Press Releases

Global Specialty Milk Formula Market - Growth, Future Prospects, Strategies, Analysis and For..

Market Research Report Store:China Cable Distribution Cabinets Market Research Report 2017

Video Transcription, Professional Voice Over Services in India

Sodium Thiocyanate Market - Growth, Share, Outlook, Strategies and Forecast 2015 - 2021: Cred..

Blepharoplasty Treatment Market Trends and Competitive Landscape Outlook to 2027

Global Video Surveillance Equipment and Services Market to Register Substantial Expansion by ..

Global Buckwheat Market Trends, Regulations And Competitive Landscape Outlook to 2027

Native Starches Market Trends and Segments 2017-2027

Global Postmenopausal Vaginal Atrophy Treatment Market by Manufacturers, Countries, Type and ..

Intel 530 Ssd Data Recovery - Recover Deleted Files from Intel 530 Series Solid State Drive

Remove this press release ?

Due to extra work required to remove the press-releases we have started charging $1.99 for press release removal.

Your press release will be removed in 24 hours, once the payment has been received.

Search Press Release
e.g. Business, Computer, etc.